Melatonin:
Medical Megamarvel or Magnificent Myth?
What I have here is an amazing
little pill that can add decades--that's right, decades--to your life. Who
among you wants to live for 120 years? Step right up . . ."
Even those street-corner medicine men of a century or so ago
couldn't have dreamed up a miracle elixir like melatonin. For starters, it promises
longevity--extra years of youthful vitality. Then it throws in some mighty
impressive health benefits as part of the bargain: immune system
enhancement, cancer protection, stress reduction, and sound sleep.
And guess what? This stuff is for real.
Bolstered by two
Newsweek cover stories extolling its virtues,
melatonin has become one hot
hormone. Consumers are scarfing
melatonin tablets by the billions, making the hormone one of the
best-selling products of its kind. (It's cheap, too--about 10 cents a
tablet.)
Most people take
melatonin for its sleep-inducing effects. Granted, there's a lot to be
said about the benefits of deep, restorative slumber. But the hormone
offers so much more than just a trendy new cure for insomnia, especially
in the anti-aging arena.
We know, for example, that melatonin is a potent--perhaps the
most potent--scavenger of those marauding molecules known as free
radicals. It thwarts the cellular degeneration that leads to heart
disease, cancer, and other debilitating health problems.
Even more exciting for us Renewal-seekers is the
discovery of melatonin's
ability to reset the body's biological clock, which determines how quickly
we age. This breakthrough prompted the following observation from Russell
Reiter, Ph.D., a cellular biologist at the University of Texas Health
Science Center at San Antonio and co-author with Jo Robinson of
Melatonin: Your Body's Natural Wonder Drug: "I want to die young as late in life as possible, and I think this
hormone could help."
Your Internal Alarm Clock
Manufacturing and secreting melatonin is the responsibility of
the pineal gland, a sunflower seedsize structure located deep within your
brain. The gland evolved from primitive eye tissue, and like a third eye,
it monitors the day/night cycle and regulates your body's rhythms. When
daylight reaches the pineal gland--traveling by way of the retinas and
optic nerves in your eyes and the nerve cells in your brain--it shuts down
production of melatonin.
Darkness, on the other hand, stimulates production.
Blood levels of
melatonin remain relatively low (around 10 picograms per milliliter)
during waking hours. Then just before bedtime, between 9:00 and 10:00 p.m.
for most people, the gland begins releasing melatonin into the bloodstream. By
about 2:00 a.m., levels of the hormone peak at around 100 picograms per
milliliter of blood. By about 7:00 or 8:00 a.m., levels return to their
low daytime state. There they stay until nightfall, when the cycle begins
all over again.
Although nighttime levels of melatonin run about 10 times higher
than daytime levels, neither quantity is exactly humongous. A picogram is
just one-trillionth of a gram, an amount that's invisible to the naked
eye. Melatonin is so potent,
though, that even microscopic specks of the stuff can send you to
dreamland for hours.
Keeping Time for a Lifetime
Longevity researchers now believe that the pineal gland does
more than regulate your 24-hour, sleep/wake clock. It may house your aging
clock, the one that drives the aging process.
As you get older, the pineal gland produces less melatonin. A growing body of
scientific literature strongly suggests--but has yet to prove--that
restoring and maintaining optimum levels of melatonin turns back the aging clock.
In this way, the hormone may extend life span.
Some of the most exciting research on this subject has been
conducted by Walter Pierpaoli, M.D., Ph.D., an immunologist at the
Biancalana-Masera Foundation for the Aged in Ancona, Italy. When Dr.
Pierpaoli gave melatonin to old mice, the hormone reversed age-related
shrinkage in the animals' thymus glands, which in turn revitalized the
animals' immune systems. Intrigued by his findings, Dr. Pierpaoli teamed
up with Vladimir A. Lesnikov of the Institute of Experimental Medicine in
St. Petersburg, Russia, to transplant the pineal glands of young mice into
old mice. The old mice were rejuvenated, their life spans extended by
one-third.
Dr. Pierpaoli and Lesnikov then flip-flopped the experiment,
transplanting the pineal glands of old mice into young mice. The results
of the experiment flip-flopped as well: This time, the life spans of the
young mice were shortened by one-third.
From these studies, Dr. Pierpaoli concluded that human aging
begins in the pineal gland. He also demonstrated that melatonin could counterbalance the
aging process. As he explains, "We should think of the pineal as the aging
clock and melatonin as a
means by which it translates its time-keeping pulses into body
changes."
Fending Off Free Radicals
Scientific understanding of melatonin has certainly come a long
way since the hormone's discovery in the 1950s. Back then, cell biologists
assumed that melatonin's sole
function was the regulation of the sleep/wake (or diurnal) cycle. Today,
of course, we know better.
With anti-aging medicine turning the spotlight on free
radical biochemistry,
melatonin has stolen the show because of its super-powerful
antioxidant properties. Indeed, researchers have concluded that the pineal
gland produces melatonin not
only to induce sleep and regulate the body's hormonal systems but also to
protect itself from free radical damage.
Of course, a properly fed body already has an ample supply
of antioxidant nutrients, including vitamins A, C, and E, coenzyme Q10, and the
antioxidant phytochemicals. What can melatonin do that these other antioxidants cannot?
Back in chapter 24, I explained how each antioxidant
nutrient specializes in servicing a particular area, or compartment, of
the body. Well, melatonin is
an exception to the rule. Its small molecular size allows the hormone to
travel anywhere within the body--even to the brain. So it provides
unequaled broad-spectrum protection against free radicals.
Melatonin is
not only more versatile but also more potent than its fellow antioxidants. The hormone appears to
have a far greater capacity for neutralizing free radicals than even the
most powerful of the known naturally occurring antioxidants. "We've tested melatonin in every conceivable system
that we can assemble," says Dr. Reiter. "It continues to perform as well
as or better than any other antioxidant." This makes sense, biochemically
speaking. It means the gland that regulates the aging process also
produces the strongest defenders against free radical attack.
Because of its antioxidant properties, melatonin may play a leading role in
the prevention and treatment of the chronic degenerative conditions caused
by the cumulative effects of oxidative stress. (Oxidative stress, you'll
recall, refers to the catastrophic cellular breakdown that occurs when
free radicals overwhelm
antioxidants.) Among the conditions linked to oxidative stress are
Alzheimer's disease, atherosclerosis (hardening and clogging of the
arteries), cancer, diabetes, multiple sclerosis, Parkinson's disease, and
rheumatoid arthritis.
Rethinking Aging
As melatonin
has gained fame, it has also revolutionized our understanding of the aging
process. In chapter 1, I described how most anti-aging experts subscribe
either to program theories or to damage theories. Program theorists
maintain that we humans are genetically destined to die at a certain age.
Damage theorists contend that the cellular wear-and-tear caused by free
radicals speeds up the aging process and eventually kills us.
The boundaries between these two schools of thought became
blurred when melatonin burst
onto the scene. In their effort to explain how the hormone turns back the
clock, experts on both sides have forged a new perspective on aging that
combines both program and damage theories.
According to the researchers, melatonin protects the pineal
gland--and the gland's preprogrammed aging clock--from free radical
damage. But as with all other hormones, melatonin production declines with
age. The resulting melatonin
shortage leaves the pineal gland vulnerable to free radical attack. The
combination of decreasing
melatonin production and increasing free radical damage accelerates
aging and precipitates physical and mental decline.
Restoring
melatonin to optimum levels protects the pineal gland and its aging
clock from free radical damage. This is how melatonin reduces oxidative stress
and extends life span.
Turning Back the Clock
The body's
melatonin production peaks while we're in our twenties, then begins a
long and slow decline. The goal of melatonin replacement therapy is to
reinstate the hormone levels of youth.
Scientists have yet to determine precisely how much melatonin is necessary to produce
optimum anti-aging effects and prolong life. But given the intense
research attention that
melatonin--and natural hormone therapy in general--has been getting
lately, I expect that we'll have some definitive answers within the next
few years.
In the meantime, dosage recommendations can vary
considerably. I have two friends--one a physician, the other a research
scientist--who have published work on the subject of melatonin. One takes 1 milligram of
the hormone nightly; the other, 30 milligrams nightly. Go figure.
So how much should you take? My advice is to stay within the
range of 0.5 to 10 milligrams per day, even though the hormone has tested
safe in much higher doses. If you're between ages 40 and 60, aim for the
low end of the range (say, 0.5 to 3 milligrams). If you're over 60, you
may want to take a tad more (2 to 6 milligrams). Within the appropriate
range, try different doses until you find one that you feel comfortable
with.
I usually don't recommend melatonin to people under 40 solely
for its anti-aging benefits. Their bodies' production of the hormone has
not yet dropped off all that dramatically.
The Immune System Stimulant
Melatonin can
recharge an immune system undermined by age-related decline. As you get
older, your thymus gland, spleen, and bone marrow--all key immune system
players--begin to atrophy. In studies, all appear to recoup their former
functionality with the help of
melatonin replacement therapy.
Interestingly, scientists have discovered melatonin receptor sites on the
surfaces of the thymus gland, spleen, and bone marrow cells. All of these
tissues appear to be revived with added melatonin. What's more, the
lymphocytes in bone marrow have
melatonin receptor sites. Research has shown that melatonin reverses age-related
declines in lymphocyte antibody production.
Melatonin also
appears to protect lymphocytes against the effects of radiation. In one
study, lymphocytes that were treated with melatonin sustained 70 percent less
damage from ionizing radiation than those that were not treated. People
who require diagnostic x-rays or who are undergoing radiation therapy may
be able to protect their healthy tissues from radiation exposure by taking
a dose of melatonin
beforehand.
If the findings of several animal studies hold up for
humans, melatonin may
rejuvenate and protect the immune system in myriad other ways. Here's a
sampling of what these studies have turned up so far.
- Mice given melatonin
produced more antibodies when exposed to an antigen. (An antigen is any
substance that induces an immune response.)
- Mice given melatonin
produced more interferon and interleu-kin-2, potent immune system
chemicals that protect against viral and bacterial infections.
- Mice given melatonin had
twice as much immunity to an encephalitis virus as mice not given the
hormone.
- Rats injected with melatonin
before and after exposure to paraquat, a toxic herbicide, showed none of
the devastating lung and liver damage experienced by unprotected
rats.
Fighting Cancer on All Fronts
Given its immune-enhancing and antioxidant properties, melatonin has the makings of a
natural cancer-fighter. Indeed, the hormone appears to inhibit development
of the disease, though perhaps in some surprising ways.
For instance,
melatonin may protect against breast cancer and other
hormone-dependent cancers by regulating the release of estrogen. The
longer a woman is exposed to estrogen over the course of her lifetime, the
greater her risk of developing a hormone-dependent cancer. Factors that
increase exposure include early onset of puberty, use of oral
contraceptives, not bearing children, late onset of menopause, and
non-natural estrogen replacement therapy.
Population studies have shown that women in countries with
high breast cancer rates have low melatonin outputs. (Melatonin output is measured by the
degree of calcification--that is, calcium salt deposits--in the pineal
gland.) The opposite also holds true: Women in countries with low breast
cancer rates have high
melatonin outputs.
Breast cancer rates also tend to be high among women who've
lost their vision. Scientists theorize that the women's pineal glands
receive minimal light stimulation, which reduces their melatonin production.
Animal studies suggest that melatonin may block the formation of
cancerous tumors. In one such study, cancer-prone mice received nightly
doses of melatonin equivalent
to human doses of one to three milligrams. After one year, only 23 percent
of the hormone-treated mice had developed tumors, compared with 62 percent
of untreated mice.
Beyond prevention,
melatonin may someday prove useful as a cancer therapy. In test tube
experiments, the hormone takes direct lethal action against breast cancer
cells and impedes the growth of prostate cancer cells. Researchers have
launched trials involving cancer patients to evaluate the hormone's
effectiveness as a treatment.
Patients with a metastatic (spreading) form of lung cancer
were given nightly 10-milligram doses of melatonin in a study conducted by Dr.
Paoli Lissoni and his colleagues at Geraldo Hospital in Milan, Italy. The
patients' one-year survival rate rose. Impressed with this result, the
researchers then added
melatonin to the interleukin-2 being given to patients with various
types of cancer. (Interleukin-2 is often used as an anti-cancer drug to
increase levels of T lymphocytes, immune cells that destroy cancer cells.)
In the presence of melatonin,
interleukin-2 was effective in a dramatically smaller dose--a godsend for
the patients since the side effects of interleukin-2 can be
horrendous.
Researchers have also used melatonin as a pretreatment for
breast cancer cells. They found that the hormone increased by 100-fold the
inhibitory effects of the breast cancer drug tamoxifen.
Number One for Slumber
As a sleep aid,
melatonin works even better than synthetic sedatives such as
barbiturates and benzodiazepenes. For starters, melatonin is effective in small doses
and produces no side effects. Plus, the hormone preserves the normal
architecture of sleep, including the timing and duration of dream phases
characterized by rapid eye movement (REM).
Anyone of any age who suffers from insomnia can benefit from
melatonin. The hormone is
especially appropriate for older people. These folks may have trouble
getting a good night's sleep because their pineal glands have cut
production of melatonin.
You needn't be a floor-pacing, sheep-counting, hard-core
insomniac to benefit from
melatonin. For people like me, who sleep okay but not always as
soundly as possible, the hormone can encourage deeper, more restorative
slumber. You feel much more refreshed the next day.
Melatonin
supplements facilitate sleep by raising blood concentrations of the
hormone from daytime levels of 10 picograms per milliliter to nighttime
levels of 100 picograms per milliliter. The supplement dose required to
achieve this increase varies from one person to the next. "Normal" doses
range from 0.3 to 6.0 milligrams, although in my experience, some stubborn
cases of insomnia have required doses as high as 20 milligrams. Your best
bet is to begin at the lower end of the range--say, 1 to 3 milligrams--and
gradually increase your dose until you find what works for you.
The type of insomnia you have determines the time you should
take melatonin for maximum
effect. For instance, if you have trouble falling asleep but no problem
staying asleep, take regular
melatonin a half-hour before bedtime. If you fall asleep easily but
then sleep shallowly or even wake up in the wee hours of the morning
(between 2:00 and 5:00 a.m.), you may get better results from taking
timed-release melatonin right
at bedtime.
Some people have both types of insomnia. If you're one of
them, you may want to experiment with a combination of regular and
timed-release melatonin
supplements.
When you first start taking melatonin, you may feel vaguely
disoriented or fuzzy-headed for the first few hours after you wake up.
This sensation should go away after a few nights of melatonin use. If it persists, you
likely need to cut back your dose.
Trouble-Free Time Travel
The Spanish king Alfonso the Wise (122184) once said, "Had I
been present at the Creation, I would have given some helpful hints." Now
I don't know what he may have had in mind. But I'd cast my vote for a body
better suited to travel across time zones.
We humans are not designed for rapid transit from one spot
on the globe to another. It leaves us with the familiar symptoms of jet
lag: fatigue, insomnia, irritability, and poor concentration. Nothing
terribly serious--but enough to spoil travel plans, whether for business
or for pleasure.
Crossing time zones catches your pineal gland off guard. The
gland expects the sun to set at more or less the same time every day. When
you change time zones, it continues secreting melatonin on the same schedule as if
you were back home. Since
melatonin controls so many of the body's internal cycles, the body is
thrown into temporary turmoil. Left to its own devices, the pineal gland
requires a few days to reset its 24-hour clock to the new time zone.
Until melatonin
supplements came along, the only real recourse against jet lag was to
tough it out until the pineal gland made the necessary adjustments. The
more time zones crossed, the greater the discombobulation, and the longer
the pineal gland needed to acclimate.
I am very sensitive to jet lag. Before melatonin supplements came along, I'd
arrive at my destination and wander around like a zombie for a couple of
days. I had to allow extra time in my travel schedules to recover from my
flights.
If you're prone to jet lag, melatonin supplements can help reset
your pineal gland when you travel from one time zone to another. My
advice: The first night that you're in the new time zone, take a dose of
melatonin at bedtime. The
size of the dose is not set in stone. Try different amounts until you
determine what works best for you. Some experts recommend taking one
milligram of melatonin for
each time zone that you cross. When I travel to the East Coast from my
home in northern California, I add five milligrams to my regular nightly
dose of melatonin. I take
this larger dose at bedtime on my first night in my destination city.
Is there any advantage to starting melatonin supplementation a few days
before you travel? No. In fact, researchers found that people who took melatonin ahead of time actually
experienced more severe jet lag symptoms. They felt even worse than people
who took placebos.
Maximizing Melatonin's Benefits
The title of this chapter asks whether melatonin is a "medical megamarvel"
or "magnificent myth." Based on the information presented here, I'd say
that the hormone lands squarely in the former category. Of course, much
research remains to be done to determine whether melatonin actually lives up to
expectations.
Right now, one absolute certainty about melatonin is its safety. When
researchers attempted to determine the lethal dose of melatonin for 50 percent of a group
of mice (the LD-50, in scientific speak), they couldn't do it. Not a
single mouse succumbed, no matter how much of the hormone it was given.
(As an animal rights advocate, I can say that I like this kind of
experiment.) The mice were, however, very well rested.
In a study involving humans, a whopping 6,000 milligrams of
melatonin--that's 1,000 times
the average effective dose--failed to produce more than occasional stomach
upset or mild foggy-headedness when taken every night for a month. Even
250 milligrams of melatonin,
administered intravenously on a nightly basis, caused no short-term or
long-term toxic reaction. Gram for gram, ordinary table salt is more toxic
than melatonin.
I've been taking
melatonin for several years now. I've prescribed it to hundreds of
patients as well. Not once have I heard of a person having an adverse
reaction to the hormone.
There are a few rules of thumb for using melatonin effectively. First, always
take the hormone just before bedtime. If you take it earlier in the day,
it can disrupt your sleep/wake cycle, which you definitely don't want.
How close the dose is to bedtime really depends on you.
Earlier in the chapter, I made specific recommendations for insomnia and
jet lag. In general, people seem to feel that melatonin works best when taken a
half-hour before bedtime. Some folks extend that window to one or even two
hours to achieve the desired effects. (If you work at night, take melatonin at your regular bedtime,
whenever that is.)
Second, if you have a serious illness of any
kind--especially leukemia, lymphoma (cancer of the lymph tissue), an
autoimmune disorder (in which immune cells attack healthy tissues), or
major depression--you should consult a doctor before beginning melatonin supplementation. The same
rule applies if you're taking any prescription medication, particularly an
immune-suppressing drug such as prednisone or cyclosporine. Melatonin is
not recommended for anyone on antidepressant medication, especially
serotonin reuptake inhibitors such as paroxetine (Paxil), fluoxetine
(Prozac), and sertraline (Zoloft) and monoamine oxidase inhibitors.
Third, if you're a woman who is pregnant or nursing,
absolutely do not take
melatonin.
Only Natural, Please
The magic of
melatonin is that it achieves its anti-aging effects without poisoning
any of the body's organs and systems in the process. The hormone fosters
internal harmony rather than undermining it, as so many prescription and
over-the-counter drugs do. With
melatonin, there is no toxicity, no risk of dependency or overdose, no
adverse reaction.
Melatonin
supplementation underscores the ultimate wisdom of using "friendly
molecules" to the greatest extent possible in the treatment and prevention
of disease. There are two types of friendly molecules: the one that your
cells make, and the one that comes from the foods you eat. (Remember, the
structure and dose must be identical.) When your biochemical
machinery--genes, enzymes, and cell membranes and receptor
sites--encounters friendly molecules, it accepts them without question. It
knows that these substances belong.
When taken in the appropriate physiologic dose (that is, the
dose that matches the amount produced by the body), a natural hormone such
as melatonin is incapable of
causing a toxic reaction. The same cannot be said of synthetic hormones,
drugs, and other unfriendly molecules. When your cells encounter these
frauds, they go into alarm/damage control/detoxification mode--the
metabolic equivalent of dialing 911. This puts your body through a
tremendous amount of stress. And stress accelerates aging.
Finding Hope in a Hormone
As an anti-aging strategy, melatonin replacement therapy works
because it targets causes of age-related decline rather than merely
masking symptoms. The road to longevity must be paved with nontoxic,
health-enhancing therapies like
melatonin and other natural hormones.
In their groundbreaking best-seller The Melatonin Miracle, Dr.
Pierpaoli and William Regelson, M.D., eloquently summarize this point
of view:
"We want you to understand that 'senescence,' the downward
spiral that is now the hallmark of aging, is not inevitable and that aging
is neither irresistible nor irreversible. It is possible to retain our
strength, sexual vigor, and love of life for all of our decades.
"The miracle of
melatonin is not just that it can extend your life and preserve your
health and vigor. The true miracle of melatonin is the wider impact that it
will have on our generation and on generations to come. We are embarking
on an adventure together. We are the first generation to have the power to
prevent the disease and the debility that have come to typify 'normal'
aging. For the first time, we have the power to preserve our youthfulness
and to stay vital and vigorous for our entire lives. For the first time,
not only are we able to prevent the physical decline associated with aging
but we're actually able to slow down and even reverse the aging process
itself. This is truly the
melatonin miracle."
Amen.
*
The sex hormones, estrogen, progesterone, and testosterone
are probably the best known of the anti-aging hormones. They're also
probably the most controversial. The next chapter sorts through all of the
conflicting information to help you decide whether any of these hormones
is right for you.
|